NAME:

POINT TOTAL:
(based on 20 possible points for each dimension for 100 total possible points)

1. Clarity - (e.g., Was the paper organized?  Did you presented the material concisely?)

Points:

Comment:
 
 
 

2. Detail - (e.g., Was the material presented accurately?  Did you go into sufficient depth?)

Points:

Comment:
 
 
 

3. Convergent Thinking - (e.g., Did you integrate theoretical concepts?  General research findings?)

Points:

Comment:
 
 
 

4. Insight - (e.g., Was the paper sophisticated psychologically?  Did you take conceptual risks?)

Points:

Comment:
 
 
 

5. Spelling, Grammar, and Style - (e.g., Were there typos?  Were sentences well-constructed?  Did you write
                                                                 with efficiency and impact?)

Points:

Comment: